Make sure a model's list has no object with that text: delete it, as the data administrator, when it is there (a run stopped half way can leave one), and again after the scenario, whatever happens in it.
Examples
Given there is no "Data step question" in the "Questions" list
Given there is no "Reviewers" in the "Groups" list
And there is no "Delete test question" in the "Questions" list
Given there is no "Test tag" in the "Tags" list
And there is no "Inline test question" in the "Questions" list
Pattern
Given(/^there is no "([^"]*)" in the "([^"]*)" list$/, …)
Part of @webship-js/django-steps (github.com/webship/django-steps), a step pack for Webship-js 2.0.x.